Gas Grills Vs. Charcoal Grills – Here Are Key Differences

Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team, nixny.com is reader-supported. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission, at no extra cost to you.

The grilling lovers in your life are sure to have strong opinions on this epic debate between charcoal and gas barbecues. What are the most important things to think about if you’re thinking about buying a grill for the first time or maybe thinking about switching from gas grills to charcoal grills or vice versa? Everything is set out here.

Charcoal Grills

In a charcoal grill, food is cooked using lump charcoal or charcoal briquettes as the heat source. Typically, the charcoal fuel is under the grill grate, and the hot coals are lit with wood chips and lighter fluid. Pellet grills, kettle grills, and chimney starts are just a few of the many forms available for charcoal barbecues.

Charcoal Grill

Pros

  1. Portable And Reasonably Priced

    There are inexpensive, compact charcoal versions that are ideal for only cooking a few burgers if you enjoy grilling when camping or tailgating for the big game. Even a somewhat more expensive model is more economical and portable than the majority of gas grilling alternatives.

  2. Become Quite Hot

    You can stoke the coals till they reach a solid 700°F with little experience and perseverance. If you want your steak to have the proper sear, this is often hotter than most gas barbecues.

  3. Master Of Authentic Grilled Taste

    The best way to achieve that char-grilled flavor is with this method, which is frequently mimicked but never completely replicated. However, if you use lighter fluid, you run the risk of getting a flavor that is more reminiscent of, well, lighter fluid.

Cons

  1. Requires A Charcoal Chimney

    A metal cylinder that is hollow and has handles and a grate inside is a charcoal chimney. You put it on top of your grill, fill it with charcoal, then heat it up with newspaper or lighter cubes. When you’re ready to start cooking, you just transfer the hot coals to your grill. It’s not overly difficult or costly (a charcoal chimney will generally cost between $10 and $15), but it does require an additional step and a piece of equipment.

  2. Cleaning Is More Irritating

    There aren’t any pots or pans to deal with or clean up, which is one advantage of grilling in the summer vs cooking in your oven or on a stove. However, charcoal barbecues may be untidy. After every usage, you’ll probably need to wipe up ash and oil, and if there’s a wind gust, you’ll also likely have to deal with ash all over your patio or deck.

  3. Could Be Forbidden

    Several apartment buildings prohibit charcoal barbecues. Usually, it has to do with the intense heat, the inability to turn them on and off, and the fact that ash and cinder actually do drift around in the wind (and potentially ignite any wood nearby). Before purchasing one, make sure to confirm any limitations.

Gas Grills

A barbecue that uses gas jets beneath the cooking surface to cook food is called a gas grill. Gas grills are typically enormous, costly, cart-style designs constructed of stainless steel that are rarely movable. In most cases, either liquid propane or natural gas is used to power these barbecues.

Gas Grill

With natural gas grills, you must connect your grill to your home’s gas line, which limits how readily you may move the grill. It may become a portable grill by adding a propane tank. But compared to propane, natural gas burns more efficiently and is more cost-effective.

Pros

  1. Simple To Use

    You may use a gas grill after using a stove. Each burner is controlled by a dial, which you use to adjust the heat and instantly switch off when you’re through. You can multitask with it since it is so simple: just turn it on, start cooking, and check in on your food every few minutes as you talk with friends, prepare the rest of supper, or even fold laundry!

  2. Happens Really Quickly

    Normally, we advise giving your gas grill 30 minutes to properly heat up, but it’s definitely safe to say that it will be hot in closer to 15 minutes. That allows you to quickly prepare your meals, giving you more time.

Cons

  1. Pricey

    Gas grill alternatives start at approximately $200, and to have one made of sturdy stainless steel that has excellent heating, will probably cost closer to $500 (although there are possibilities that cost far over a thousand dollars!).

  2. Gas Is A Need

    If you choose to own a gas grill, you must be able to fuel it, either by maintaining a propane tank that is full or by using a natural gas line that is linked to your home. Since installing a gas connection to your outside space is expensive, most people choose propane tanks. A genuine tank costs roughly $20 to purchase, and it costs another $20 to fill it (how often depends on how much you use it!).

Gas Vs Charcoal: Where They Differ?

  1. Taste

    A gas grill will cook your food with a cleaner flavour than a charcoal barbecue, which will impart a smokey flavour. You may purchase a smoke box to give your meal a smoky flavour if you want the smoke flavour of a charcoal barbecue on a gas grill.

  2. Control

    Compared to a charcoal grill, which requires some time for the coals to heat up, a gas grill warms up considerably more quickly. For those who wish to cook meals fast, gas grills are a preferable choice. Because you have more control over how heat is dispersed throughout the various components of the cooking grate, gas grills can be more adaptable. Controlling the heat settings on a charcoal grill is more challenging than on a gas grill.

  3. Cost

    Generally speaking, a charcoal barbecue is less expensive than a gas grill. Charcoal grills may be purchased for as little as $30, depending on the model. However, heating a charcoal barbecue with gasoline might wind up costing more than heating a propane gas grill. Much more quickly than you would use up the contents of a propane tank, charcoal fuel is simple to burn through.

  4. Temperature For Cooking

    Usually able to handle a larger temperature range, charcoal grills may reach 1200 degrees Fahrenheit. The majority of propane gas barbecues only get up to 600 degrees F. Although some gas grills can achieve extremely high temperatures, their cost is often more than that of standard gas barbecues. But temperature regulation is considerably simpler by using a propane grill.

FAQs

Is Gas Or Charcoal Preferable?


The convenience of gas grills may be slightly superior on a daily basis, but many people prefer the flavor of charcoal. For more diverse cooking possibilities, some people even decide to acquire both varieties. You can’t go wrong with any style of grill because their cleanup times, maximum temperatures, and maintenance requirements are equal.

Does The Flavour Of Food Cooked On A Gas Barbecue Or A Charcoal Grill Differ?


Foods cooked on charcoal grills typically have a smokier taste. Although the combustion of the complex organic molecules in the charcoal results in fragrant chemicals, charcoal grills nevertheless emit a lot of smoke. The interaction between the smoke and aromatic chemicals and the food gives it a char-grilled flavour that enhances the depth of flavour in foods like steak and poultry. Consider a kamado grill, which gently smokes meat, for the best possible Smokey flavour.

Gas grills create less smoke, and when fully combusted, gas only produces water and carbon dioxide due to its smaller molecule. Therefore, while gas grills produce food with a less pronounced flavour, this is a benefit for grilling delicate foods like fish, vegetables, fruits, and seafood.

Should I Get A Gas Or Charcoal Grill?


Both charcoal and gas grills have advantages and disadvantages, but only you can determine which is ideal for your family and way of life. There are so many mouth watering grilling dishes to prepare this summer that you can’t go wrong.

A gas and charcoal combination grill is something to take into consideration if you’re having problems deciding.

Conclusion

Two of the most popular grill kinds are gas and charcoal grills. There may be an unending discussion about the relative benefits of gas and charcoal barbecues, but none is unquestionably superior than the other. When choosing, take your own demands and tastes into account.

Rate this post
Evelyn Brown

Evelyn Brown is a housewife and spends most of the time at home taking care of her infant son. The time that she has left after cleaning the house and taking care of the son and the daddy is dedicated to making her mark on the internet. She loves to write about the kitchen appliances that she uses in her daily life. She also likes to spend quality time with her husband and drink aged wine and scotch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.